Choose an image from a movie or TV program from the
lists below. Write a commentary on any ONE aspect of either narrative OR mise
en scene in terms of its importance to storytelling.
This image represents the “all is lost” moment
within the film, primarily with the use of the mise en scene techniques of
lighting and colour. The exemption of colour from this shot and the use of
shades of black, grey and white signal that the story has taken a bad turn.
Evil has captured the destroyed city of Chicago, with the dark lighting of the
scene enabling the premise of evil being present. The overall lighting of the
scene is primarily dark; however the backgrounded sky suggests daytime, which
accentuates the bleakness of the story at this point.
Back lighting is formed by the sky over the city
which is in bright contrast to the rest of the image. This technique allows for
a granule of hope to remain and further the storyline as light in a dark
setting is associated with a fast approaching positive outcome. In addition to
this, the bleak and monotonous setting, which is unlike any previous shots
throughout the film, conveys most clearly that this point is the lowest of the
film. This serves as the catalyst for
the heroes of the story to take action against the evil that occupies the city
and extend the light hovering on the horizon.
Commentary 1: Good solid analysis here – particularly around Bilbo’s character arc, and character traits. A little more engagement with key narrative terms/concepts (causality, equilibrium, three act structure, character-driven causality etc) would have strengthened your insights.
ReplyDeleteCommentary 2: Good strong analysis here. You pull apart story and themes in relation to camera and mise en scene well. Nice.
Commentary 3 (transformers): Quite strong analysis here. Discussion of this point in the overall structure of the film would help pull out overarching themes and give the scene more context. But your analysis of lighting and how it relates to hope etc is insightful.
Overall your entries display a good general ability to undertake film analysis. Situating your analysis a little more within broader themes may strengthen your work. Congratulations, Part A is now passed and complete!